Aexus Answers

Fixing `manhattanDistance` In AntV X6 V3 Custom Routers

Alex Johnson
-
Fixing `manhattanDistance` In AntV X6 V3 Custom Routers

Hey there, fellow developers and diagram enthusiasts! If you've been working with AntV X6, especially when migrating from version 2 to version 3, you might have stumbled upon a rather tricky error related to custom routing: the infamous from.manhattanDistance is not a function message. It can be quite a head-scratcher, especially when your custom Manhattan router worked perfectly fine in v2. Don't worry, you're not alone! This article is all about demystifying this error, understanding why it happens in AntV X6 v3, and, most importantly, guiding you through the steps to fix it and get your custom routes flowing smoothly again. We'll dive deep into the changes between versions, explore the underlying Point object structures, and provide practical solutions to ensure your custom routing logic shines in the latest AntV X6 environment. Get ready to conquer those routing challenges!

Understanding AntV X6 and Custom Routers

AntV X6 is an incredibly powerful and flexible JavaScript library designed for building interactive diagrams, flowcharts, ER diagrams, and much more. It's a fantastic tool for visualizing complex relationships and processes, giving developers the ability to create highly customizable and engaging user experiences. At its core, X6 allows you to define nodes and edges, and then beautifully renders them on a canvas. What makes X6 truly stand out is its extensibility, particularly when it comes to customizing how edges are drawn. This is where custom routers come into play, and they are absolutely crucial for achieving specific visual layouts and meeting unique application requirements.

Think about it: standard routing might give you straight lines or simple curves, but what if you need edges that strictly follow orthogonal (horizontal and vertical) paths, mimicking the look of circuit boards or architectural blueprints? That's where a Manhattan router becomes your best friend. A Manhattan router ensures that all segments of an edge are either perfectly horizontal or perfectly vertical, often producing a cleaner, more organized aesthetic for many types of diagrams. While AntV X6 provides built-in routers, the true power lies in being able to define your own custom routing logic. This allows you to implement specific algorithms, bypass obstacles, or integrate complex business rules into how your connections are drawn. Whether it's to avoid overlapping nodes, create aesthetically pleasing paths, or simply to adhere to a particular design guideline, custom routers are an indispensable feature for any serious X6 project. They essentially give you complete control over the geometric path an edge takes between its source and target points. When you embark on creating a custom router, you're essentially providing a function that tells X6, "Hey, given these two points and any intermediate points, draw the edge exactly like this." This level of control is super valuable but also means that any underlying changes in the library's core structures, especially how it represents points or performs geometric calculations, can significantly impact your custom code. This brings us directly to the challenges faced when migrating from X6 v2 to v3, particularly concerning how geometric utilities like manhattanDistance are exposed and expected to behave.

The manhattanDistance Mystery: Why It Fails in X6 v3

If you've migrated your AntV X6 custom router from v2 to v3, you might have been met with a rather cryptic error message: from.manhattanDistance is not a function. This error, while frustrating, is a strong indicator of a fundamental change in how AntV X6 v3 handles its internal geometric objects, specifically its Point instances. In X6 v2, it was quite common for the from and to points passed to your custom routing function to be instances of a Point class that had various useful methods directly attached to its prototype, including manhattanDistance. This made it incredibly convenient to calculate the Manhattan distance between points right within your custom logic. You could just call from.manhattanDistance(to) and expect it to work seamlessly. Ah, the good old days!

However, AntV X6 v3 brought with it a significant architectural refactor, especially concerning its Geometry module. The core issue lies in how Point objects are now structured and inherited. In v3, the point objects you receive in your router might no longer have manhattanDistance directly on their prototype. Instead, they might be simpler { x, y } objects, or instances of a Geometry class that doesn't expose manhattanDistance as an instance method on the Point.PointLike interface by default. This change was likely made to streamline the core library, separate concerns, and potentially optimize performance or reduce bundle size by moving utility methods to static helpers rather than instance methods. The Geometry module in v3 is more of a collection of static utility functions and classes (Geom.Point, Geom.Line, Geom.Path, etc.) rather than a system where every single point object comes pre-loaded with every possible geometric method. So, when your v2 custom router tries to access from.manhattanDistance, the JavaScript runtime simply can't find that method on the from object, leading to the dreaded is not a function error. It's like asking a simple { x: 10, y: 20 } object to calculate its own Manhattan distance—it simply doesn't know how because it's just raw data, not an object with that specific method. This shift means that developers need to adapt their approach to geometric calculations within custom routers, moving away from relying on instance methods and towards using the new static utility methods provided by X6's Geom module, or even implementing simple helper functions themselves. Understanding this underlying change in object structure and method exposure is key to successfully migrating your custom routing logic and overcoming this particular v3 hurdle. It’s not a bug, but rather a different, arguably cleaner, design philosophy that requires a slight adjustment in our coding habits when interacting with geometric primitives.

Decoding the Solution: Restoring manhattanDistance for X6 v3 Custom Routers

Alright, so we understand why from.manhattanDistance is not a function in AntV X6 v3. Now, let's talk about how to fix it! The good news is that solving this problem isn't overly complicated; it just requires a small adjustment to how we perform geometric calculations in our custom routers. The core idea is to move away from expecting manhattanDistance to be an instance method on the Point objects themselves and instead utilize either X6's provided geometric utilities or a simple custom helper function.

Option 1: Leveraging X6's Geom.Point Utilities

AntV X6 v3 comes with a robust Geom module, which contains static utility methods for various geometric operations. While there might not be a direct Geom.Point.manhattanDistance method, we can certainly use Geom.Point.distance and specify the metric, or simply calculate it ourselves using the coordinates. Remember, Manhattan distance is simply the sum of the absolute differences of the x and y coordinates. So, if you have two points, p1 = { x: x1, y: y1 } and p2 = { x: x2, y: y2 }, the Manhattan distance is |x1 - x2| + |y1 - y2|.

Here's how you might integrate this into your custom router:

import { Graph, Path, Shape, Geom } from '@antv/x6';

// Define your custom router function
const customManhattanRouter = (vertices, options, edgeView) => {
  const { sourcePoint, targetPoint } = edgeView;
  const points = [sourcePoint, ...vertices, targetPoint];

  // A simple helper function for Manhattan distance
  const getManhattanDistance = (pA, pB) => {
    if (!pA || !pB) return 0;
    return Math.abs(pA.x - pB.x) + Math.abs(pA.y - pB.y);
  };

  // Now, use getManhattanDistance wherever you need it
  // For example, in a pathfinding algorithm or sorting logic:
  // let closestPoint = null;
  // let minDistance = Infinity;
  // for (const p of someOtherPoints) {
  //   const dist = getManhattanDistance(sourcePoint, p);
  //   if (dist < minDistance) {
  //     minDistance = dist;
  //     closestPoint = p;
  //   }
  // }

  // ... rest of your custom routing logic ...
  // The original problem mentions that manhattan router does not include start and end points.
  // This suggests you're building a path with intermediate vertices.
  // You'd use Geom.Point.create() or similar if you need X6 Point objects
  // For pure distance calculation, plain {x, y} objects are fine.

  // Example of using Geom.Point if you need more complex operations later
  // const p1Geom = Geom.Point.create(sourcePoint.x, sourcePoint.y);
  // const p2Geom = Geom.Point.create(targetPoint.x, targetPoint.y);
  // You can then use Geom.Point's static methods for calculations, 
  // but for simple Manhattan distance, the helper is often clearer.

  // Your routing algorithm would then construct a Path segment array
  // using these points and potentially calculated intermediate points.
  // Example (simplified, actual router logic is more complex):
  const pathSegments = [];
  for (let i = 0; i < points.length - 1; i++) {
    const p1 = points[i];
    const p2 = points[i + 1];
    // Add logic here to create orthogonal segments between p1 and p2
    // This is where a custom Manhattan path generation would occur.
    // For instance, you might generate a horizontal then vertical segment, or vice-versa.
    pathSegments.push(new Path.Segment('M', p1.x, p1.y)); // Move to start
    pathSegments.push(new Path.Segment('L', p2.x, p2.y)); // Draw line to next point
  }

  return pathSegments;
};

// Register your custom router with X6
Graph.registerRouter('customManhattan', customManhattanRouter, true);

// Usage in your edge definition:
// graph.addEdge({
//   source: { cell: 'node1', port: 'port1' },
//   target: { cell: 'node2', port: 'port2' },
//   router: 'customManhattan',
//   // ... other edge properties
// });

Option 2: Custom Helper Function (As demonstrated above)

The most straightforward and often cleanest solution is to simply define your own small utility function for manhattanDistance right within your custom router or as a separate helper. This gives you full control and avoids relying on potentially changing internal library methods. As shown in the code snippet above, a getManhattanDistance function using Math.abs is perfectly suitable and extremely efficient. The key here is to realize that the from and to objects you receive often have simple x and y properties, which are all you need for basic geometric calculations. By using a custom function, you effectively decouple your routing logic from the specific internal implementation details of X6's Point objects in different versions, making your code more robust and easier to maintain across future updates. Just remember to import Geom if you plan to use its other utilities, but for manhattanDistance, a simple helper is often the most direct path to success.

Practical Implementation Steps and Best Practices

Migrating custom logic, especially when dealing with core library changes, requires a methodical approach. Here's a step-by-step guide to help you successfully implement the fix for the manhattanDistance issue in your AntV X6 v3 custom routers, along with some general best practices for smoother migrations.

Step-by-Step Guide to Fixing Your Router

  1. Identify the Calls: Go through your existing AntV X6 v2 custom router code and pinpoint every instance where from.manhattanDistance() or somePoint.manhattanDistance() is being called. These are the specific lines that are causing the is not a function error in v3. You'll likely find these within your pathfinding or vertex sorting algorithms, where you need to calculate distances between various points to determine the optimal route segments.
  2. Choose Your Solution: Based on the previous section, decide whether you want to implement a simple inline getManhattanDistance helper function or if you prefer to use Geom.Point utilities for consistency with other X6 operations. For plain Manhattan distance, a helper function (e.g., (pA, pB) => Math.abs(pA.x - pB.x) + Math.abs(pA.y - pB.y)) is often the quickest and most readable approach.
  3. Replace and Adapt: Replace each identified manhattanDistance call with your chosen solution. For example, if you had sourcePoint.manhattanDistance(targetPoint), you would change it to getManhattanDistance(sourcePoint, targetPoint). Remember that the from and to points (or sourcePoint and targetPoint in router arguments) are now likely plain { x, y } objects, making direct property access (.x, .y) perfectly valid.
  4. Handle from and to Points: In X6 custom routers, the arguments typically provide sourcePoint and targetPoint (often as part of the edgeView object). Ensure your custom router correctly accesses sourcePoint.x, sourcePoint.y, targetPoint.x, targetPoint.y, and any intermediate vertices as plain objects. Your helper function should be designed to accept these simple object structures.
  5. Thorough Testing: This is critical. After making the changes, rigorously test your custom router. Drag edges from connection points, move nodes, and try different configurations to ensure that the paths are generated correctly and that the error no longer appears. Pay close attention to edge cases, such as very short distances or edges crossing complex layouts, to confirm the new distance calculation behaves as expected.

General Tips for AntV X6 Migrations

  • Read the Official Migration Guide: Always, always start with the official AntV X6 migration guide (if available for your specific version jump). It will outline breaking changes and recommended updates. This is your most authoritative source for understanding what has changed under the hood.
  • Understand Geometry and Point Structures: Dedicate some time to understanding the new Geom module and how Point objects are represented in X6 v3. The shift from instance methods to static utilities is a common pattern in library evolutions and affects how you interact with these foundational elements.
  • Utilize X6's Geom Utilities: Beyond Point distances, the Geom module offers a wealth of utilities for lines, paths, and other shapes. Familiarize yourself with these. Using X6's built-in utilities where possible can lead to more robust and performant code than reinventing the wheel.
  • Incremental Migration: If your project is large, try to migrate components incrementally. Tackle one custom router or one problematic area at a time. This makes debugging much easier and reduces the risk of introducing multiple issues simultaneously.
  • Check the Community and Issues: If you encounter new errors, search the AntV X6 GitHub issues or forums. Chances are, someone else has faced a similar problem, and you might find solutions or workarounds posted by the community or the maintainers.

By following these steps, you'll not only fix the manhattanDistance error but also gain a deeper understanding of AntV X6 v3's architecture, making future customizations and updates much smoother. Happy diagramming!

Conclusion

Navigating library upgrades can sometimes feel like solving a puzzle, and the from.manhattanDistance is not a function error in AntV X6 v3 custom routers is a perfect example of such a challenge. We've explored how the underlying architectural changes in X6's Point and Geometry modules between v2 and v3 led to this specific issue, requiring a shift from relying on instance methods to using more explicit utility functions or custom helpers. The good news is that with a clear understanding of these changes and a straightforward approach to implementing a Manhattan distance calculation, you can quickly get your custom routing logic back on track.

Remember, adapting to library evolutions is a crucial part of software development. By understanding why things change, reading documentation, and embracing new patterns (like using static Geom utilities or simple custom functions), you empower yourself to build more resilient and future-proof applications. Your diagrams will continue to be as dynamic and visually appealing as ever, now with the added stability of AntV X6 v3. Keep experimenting, keep building, and don't hesitate to dive into the specifics when things don't work as expected. The AntV X6 community is always there to help!

For further reading and official resources, check out these trusted links:

You may also like